What Is The Difference Between Bark Collar And Training Collar? Compared

Last Updated on July, 2022

Are you trying to get into training dogs but don’t quite know all the details? You aren’t alone on that boat.

Most owners don’t know about these things initially, and there’s nothing wrong with that. However, it’s easy to learn more about the different collars out there with a bit of searching.

Speaking of which, two of the main ones out there are bark collars and shock collars. These are distinct in many ways, including their functions, features, and more. That’s why we’ve done our fair share of research to prepare this article.

If you’re interested in learning more about the difference between bark collar and training collar, we’ve got you covered. Continue reading to learn the most important details!

Here are the 3 key points from this article:

  1. Bark collars and shock collars are two different types of collars used to train dogs. 
  2. Bark collars are automatic and use a jolt of electricity to distract the dog from barking. 
  3. Shock collars are manual and use different correction methods, including static stimulation, vibration and tone.

TLDR: Bark collars automatically correct excessive barking, while training collars require manual operation and offer more control. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, so it really depends on your needs as to which one is better for you.

What Are Bark Collars?

Does your pup tend to bark a bit too much

Does he go haywire whenever he sees anything interesting? 

Keeps you up at night while you try to sleep with unnecessary barking

Bothers the neighbors with his bark? Well, welcome to the club.

The best way to train them to avoid situations like these is to use a bark control collar. These can get any dog to stop barking with careful training.

You wrap this training tool around a dog’s neck, and it takes care of everything for you after that. Every bark collar has bark sensors. These can automatically identify excessive barking and use a particular method to correct the dog’s bad behavior.

Different kinds of bark collars use other correction methods for barking behavior. Most of them use a shock function. So if your dog tends to bark excessively, the automatic bark sensing technology will pick it up. Then, it’ll release a subtle jolt of electricity.

This isn’t painful for the pup at all. On the contrary, it’s strong enough to distract the little guy from his barking and shift the dog’s attention towards the collar instead.

Training a dog with collar

Other various types of bark collars feature less direct modes. This includes bark collars which let out an ultrasonic sound that only your dog can hear. This doesn’t hurt his ears but provides a bit of discomfort so that he stops barking.

There are also vibrating bark collars. They use a strong vibration instead of static stimulation to deal with excessive barking.

Lastly, there is also the spray collar that releases some liquid on the dog’s nose. This liquid is usually a citronella solution, which dogs hate because of the citrus in them.

Dogs are smart enough to know that the collar is doing these things to them because of wrong actions. As a result, the puppy will let go of his unwanted behaviors and listen to the owner more often.

It’s crucial to keep in mind that these devices should never stay on a puppy for long. Your dog will lose his patience if the collar keeps on correcting him for hours without end. 

You should not keep the bark collar on your dog for more than 8 to 10 hours per day. A bark collar might even inflict pain if kept on too long. If you keep them on for longer periods, they might even cause Pressure Necrosis.

It’s also essential to make sure that the collar isn’t too tight. It’s not good for the dog’s skin. (1)

This means trouble for the relationship between pet owners and their pets. That’s why you’re supposed to remove the device and store it away until the next time it’s needed.

Recommended to read: Bark Collar vs Shock Collar

What are Dog Training Collars?

Dog Training Collar

A remote training collar is a little more complicated compared to a bark collar. That’s because remote training collars don’t automatically go off whenever your dog barks. Also known as e-collars, these little devices are manual.

You’ll use an e-collar and handheld device to operate it. This isn’t a bad thing, as the remote training collar offers more control. Also, much like the bark collar, they use similar correction training options. 

The dog training collar lets you choose between these different correction training modes. Most modern variations of the device allow you to determine which type of correction is administered.

Shock, ultrasonic, spray, vibration collars, and much more are merged into one single handheld device. The remote control lets you switch between all these.

This gives the dog trainer a choice and lets them decide which method is best for their dog. In addition, you can associate various commands with various modes.

For example, You can use static stimulation to teach dogs specific training commands. In comparison, you can use vibrations to teach other basic commands.

This variety in options comes in very handy, which is precisely why e-collars are so popular. It’s great for targeting bad behavioral traits and keeping dogs in line during training.

Also read: E-Collar vs. Shock Collar: Is There Any Difference?

The Main Differences Between Them

Difference Between Bark Collar And Training Collar

The main difference between bark collar and training collar systems is that one does its job while the other relies on the trainer. But, as already suggested, this isn’t a bad thing at all.

It makes remote-controlled electronic collars preferable options. A bark collar performs its operation, and the intensity is usually out of your hands too. Additionally, stubborn dogs and large dogs might get used to it after a while.

But in the case of training collars, there’s the low-level shock, high-level shock, and everything between. Trainers control all this. From the intensity of the correction to precisely what method of correction is being used.

You aren’t always at home to look after your dog, though, are you? So it might make a ruckus while you’re gone, which is precisely where the bark collar comes in handy.

As long as it’s on the dog’s neck, it’ll train dogs to stop barking. Then, while you’re away from home, it’ll watch over your little buddy and make sure he doesn’t make too much noise.

Despite how versatile it is, this isn’t possible with a dog training collar. You have to keep an eye on your dog and administer correction accordingly. On top of this, there’s a set range that the remote works in.

It all depends on how often you’re home. If you’re away from your dog a lot, it’s better to let bark collars handle training for you. But, if you’re usually around the little guy, we recommend using a training collar to condition his behavior because it’s a better option manually.

Long story short, there are advantages and disadvantages to both, which is precisely what makes the decision so challenging.

Related: Different kinds of dog collars

What’s Better for You?

Dog wearing bark collar

There are significant differences among both, but you can’t say which one’s better. That’s because both function differently. You’ll only get to know which one’s better for you depending on your needs.

Considering how much both of these collars have to offer, you’ll undoubtedly find them handy. But, again, you cannot say that one is better than the other.


Both the bark collar and remote training collar are excellent in their way. But, in the end, it all depends on what kind of training you’re looking to take care of.

If the only problem at hand is that your dog barks too much, then get a bark collar. That’ll take care of the job for you—all you have to do is make sure that you don’t keep the collar on for too long.

But, if the issue is more complicated than that, dog owners should get a training collar. These don’t have a specific target audience. Anyone can control them to train their dogs.

We guarantee that trainers will find both collars of outstanding service as long as they choose right. We’ve laid out the facts. All that’s left for you is to examine your dog’s needs and wants to determine the preferred option!



  1. https://www.petmd.com/dog/care/5-ways-collars-can-harm-your-dog

Leave a Comment