10 Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs (Buyer’s Guide)

Last Updated on May, 2024

Dogs are our best friends, but a stubborn dog can make you go crazy… 

Ever had to shout your lungs out to make your dog listen? (We’ve all been there)

The good news is that you can train stubborn dogs; it just takes a bit more effort. If hiring an expensive, professional dog trainer is not an option, using a shock collar is your best bet.

But picking the best training collar for stubborn dogs is another challenge.

We reviewed the best dog training collars for stubborn pups to make things easier for you. We also summarized the features, pros, and cons of the top 10 dog shock collars. 

So continue reading to find out the ultimate dog training collar for your stubborn pup.

Editor’s Choice
Pet Resolve Product Image
Pet Resolve PTS1200
Range
Effectiveness
Price

5.0

5.0

5.0

Overall Score

5.0

#2nd Best Choice
HALO Dog Collar Product Image
Halo 2+
Range
Effectiveness
Price

4.9

5.0

4.9

Overall Score

4.9

#3rd Best Choice
SportDOG 425X product image
Sportdog 425x
Range
Effectiveness
Price

5.0

4.7

4.8

Overall Score

4.8

10 Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs 

Here are our top 10 picks for the best training collar for stubborn dogs.

1. Pet Resolve PTS1200 (Editor’s Choice)

A cheap, simple, versatile, and effective dog training collar is the Pet Resolve.

To handle your Hard-headed furry friend, this is the first thing you need to have in your arsenal. 

Before fitting it in your arsenal, let’s look at whether or not it’ll fit your dog; Pet Resolve comes with an adjustable collar that can fit dogs that are 15lbs or above, that’s most probably the medium to large sized category

Proper fit? 

Ok then, let’s move on…

To kick things off, versatility is one of the important aspects when it comes to training, and Pet Resolve excels in that in every single way.

You get three feedback modes for training; Beep, Vibration, and Shock, all of which work excellently well. Out of the three, both vibration and shock are adjustable too.

There are ten continuous and momentary stimulation intensity levels, and you can pick the one that your dog responds to the most. 

You might need to try different variations in order to get control of your stubborn pup; Pet Resolve provides some great ways of doing that.

Moving on, the range of connection between the collar and the transmitter is another area why Pet Resolve is in this position. 3960 ft (¾ mile), that’s in the top tier when it comes to dog training collars. 

Training indoors, in the yard, or in the park is all a breeze with that type of range. You can even rely on that for hiking and hunting trips too.

Speaking of hunting, not many hunting collars provide this type of range. So if you own a hunting dog, this collar will be a perfect fit. 

The one feature that most other training collars overlook is present in this one. Support for long-haired dogs. With almost every other training collar, you’ll need to trim the hair where the contact point goes to get the proper fit.

With Pet Resolve, you can just remove the contact points and attach the long ones included in the box. That’s the kind of versatility I was talking about. 

It does not end there; you can also convert Pet Resolve into a full-on vibration-only collar once your dog gets used to shock. This isn’t about changing only the mode; it’s removing both metal contact points and replacing them with plastic ones. 

A vibration collar at no extra cost! SWEET… 

Out of all, one feature that had me surprised was the anti-bark mode. If your dog goes on a Bark-a-thon when you’re not around, Pet Resolve will take care; it will detect your dog’s barking and correct it immediately.

This will stop your dog from being a barkzilla with zero effort from your side.

A bark collar at no extra cost! EVEN SWEET… 

Pet Resolve can also resolve your issues when it comes to owning multiple dogs; it can handle up to three dogs at once with a single remote if you purchase extra collars. 

Finally, there’s the waterproofing aspect; the collar is fully waterproof, and the transmitter is splashproof. Training in the rain, on the beach, does need to stop now.

That is not everything Pet Resolve has to offer; there’s more, and you need to get your hands on one to experience. It’s a great dog training collar with a lot of training features allowing to train even the most stubborn of dogs. 

Pros

Collar and the transmitter are excellently durable
Collar has a built-in LED light which increases visibility at night during walks
Memory function that remembers the modes and intensity levels you last used
Rechargeable collar and transmitter with 50 to 60 hours battery runtime with constant use
Super easy to use the device
Superb range
Multi-dog system
2-year warranty

Cons

The remote does not have the ability to turn off the receiver (collar)

2. Halo 2+ (#2nd Best Choice)

If money is no object and you want the bleeding edge best of the best dog training collar on the market, Halo 2+ might be the one for you.

Training stubborn dogs does not get much easier than this. Halo 2+ simply offers everything you need to train your dog and more. 

For starters, it’s not just a training collar but also a wireless dog fence system and a real-time GPS tracking device.

That is everything to train your dog and keep it safe and secure. 

Let’s get into more detail.

First of all, if you’re dealing with a stubborn dog, it’s important that you have a collar with multiple intensity levels and modes, and Halo has that.

Four training modes, that’s more than any other collars on the market.

Four of the modes are Tone, Voice, Vibration, and Static Feedback; since you’re dealing with a stubborn dog, static feedback should be your option, at least for the first few training sessions.

Static mode on Halo 2+ provides you with 15 levels of intensity that help you cater training towards the temperament of your dog. 

Halo 2+ fulfills the main aspects of training just right, and you can see it yourself. 

Another aspect of the Halo 2+ that makes it a great collar for training is the range. Of all the collars I’ve laid my hands on, this has the best one yet. 6.2 miles of land space for you to train your dog,

What more could you ask?

That 6.2 miles of range can also be tailored to your needs. If you’re training your dog in a smaller space, the range can be adjusted according to that; however, it cannot be as small as 30 feet. 

It is uncommon to come across a collar of this type that offers an adjustable range; this is great. 

Achieving that max range is a little different in Halo compared to other collars; here, you should create virtual fences. I already said that this is a wireless dog fence. You can create 20 virtual fences, and that is where you’ll be training your dog. 

The fences you’ll be creating are what can be as big as 6.2 miles, and that is what acts as the range for training. 

A little complicated stuff, but you’ll understand once you try it in person. And as for the effectiveness, nothing comes close.

Halo is a dog collar that not only contains your dog but also includes all the necessary tools for training it effectively. There’s no better way to tame down your stubborn canine partner. 

Real-time GPS tracking is also present in Halo, that’ll help you keep an eye on your dog 24/7 via your mobile phone. Speaking of phones, the collar is completely controlled with the phone; it does not come with a remote like all the other training collars. 

This is just a peak of everything that Halo can offer; there’s so much to it that cannot be listed in this short review; you just have to try for yourself. 

Pros

Dog training, tracking, containing; All in one
Battery runtime 21 hours with a single charge
Durable collar and IP67 water and dust resistant rated
Comfortable and excellent design
Top-of-the-line range
Four modes for training
15 adjustable intensity levels

Cons

Expensive

3. Sportdog 425x Remote Training Dog Collar (#3rd Best Choice)

Sportdog 425x Remote Training Dog Collar is definitely one of the best training collar for stubborn dogs.

This collar will fit any dog over 8 lbs with a neck size of 5-22 inches.

It is an expensive option, but if you look at what if offers, it’s totally worth every penny.

When it comes to picking the correct stimulation level for your dog, this collar gives you many options.

The shock collar has three training modes: vibration, tone, and static stimulation. In addition, there are three static stimulation ranges: low, medium, and high.

And that’s not all; each stimulation level has 21 levels to choose from! 

With a range of 500 yards (1500 ft), this e-collar is ideal for both indoor and field training. 

This training collar is fully waterproof and submersible in 25 ft of water, perfect for dogs that love water.

You can train up to three dogs with one remote. Of course, you have to buy additional collars separately.

This training system has long-lasting battery life. The battery life is about 50-70 hours, depending on how much you use the system. The good battery life lets you have long training sessions without interruption.

A wide range of stimulations, excellent range, waterproof ability, and durability secured the 425x the third spot on our list.

Pros

3 ranges of static stimulation with 21 levels in each range!
The collar receiver is waterproof
1500 ft range

Cons

The remote control is not waterproof
It’s quite difficult to adjust the settings

4. Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar takes the third spot on our best training collars for stubborn dogs list.

Educator is a well-known e-collar brand with a wide range of shock collars.

With a unique stopwatch design for easy operations, this e-collar is perfect for dogs with neck sizes of 30 inches.

Three training modes (beep, vibration mode, and shock mode) let you pick the best training method for your dog.

There are 100 levels of shock to choose from. Another plus is the 60 booster levels for emergencies.

Educator E-Collar Product Image

Finally, the higher static stimulation range is perfect for even the most stubborn dogs.

A very useful lock and set feature in the remote allows you to set the right stimulation level for your dog.

The 2640 ft (½ mile) range makes this collar perfect for long-distance training.

Both the collar receiver and the transmitter are fully waterproof, so you don’t have to worry about dropping them in water or getting caught in the rain.

This remote dog training collar comes with a handy LED light feature. The LED light lets you spot your dog in low visibility conditions.

Educator have both one and two dog systems. So you can train up to two dogs simultaneously. However, the training system comes with one collar, so you have to buy the additional collar separately.

The remote trainer comes with rechargeable lithium batteries. It takes just 2 hours to charge the batteries fully, and batteries last a long time so that you can have long training sessions.

Pros

The collar has a LED light
Long-range of 2640 ft
Fully waterproof e-collar and remote
100 stimulation levels with 60 booster levels

Cons

It can be a bit confusing to use the remote for the first time

5. Garmin Delta Xc 

Garmin Delta Xc is another great remote trainer.

With three training modes (tone, vibration, and shock) and 18 intensities of shock, this collar is perfect for stubborn dogs.

You can also pick between continuous and momentary stimulation. Continuous stimulation is ideal if your dog doesn’t respond during an emergency.

A simple, 3 button layout makes the remote easy to operate. The remote also has an LCD screen display.

The 2640 ft range makes this shock collar great for long-distance field training and indoor corrections.

Both the handheld remote and the dog collar are IPX7 waterproof. This system is perfect for all water-loving dogs out there.

Garmin Delta XC Collar Product Image

The remote is a multi-dog training system. You can train 1,2, or 3 dogs with this training system by buying extra collars separately.

Good battery power means long and effective training sessions. The rechargeable lithium batteries in the receiver and the transmitter have great battery life. The handheld remote holds a single charge for 80 hours, while the collar has a battery life of 60 hours. 

Pros

IPX7 waterproof collar and remote
(2640 ft) half mile range
Good battery life
Can train up to three dogs

Cons

There are signal issues at longer ranges

6. Petspy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar

The Petspy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar is adjustable to fit dogs of all breeds between 10-140 lbs in size.

With tone, vibration, and shock modes and 16 levels of shock, you can easily pick the best stimulation for your dog.

A 1950 ft range lets you easily command your dog from a distance. This range is good for both in-house and field training.

The handheld remote is very user-friendly. You can distinguish the buttons easily. This easy-to-use layout is perfect if you want to focus on your dog and not the remote.

With a 100% waterproof remote and collar, this training system is perfect for rainy weather and dogs that love water.

PetSpy P620 Collar Product Image

This training system is expandable to train two dogs at once. You have to buy the additional collars separately.

A dual fast charging system allows you to charge the remote and the collar rapidly.

With every purchase, you will get a free e-book on dog training. The e-book is a perfect training guide for new dog parents.

Pros

100% waterproof collar
Easily operable remote
1950 ft range

Cons

The collar can stop charging at times

7. Patpet Dog Shock Collar 

Patpet Dog Shock Collar is a great pick for those who want a good range.

This adjustable collar fits dogs between 8-120 lbs with neck sizes of 7-25 inches. The collar is lightweight and is suitable for puppies as well.

This e-collar has three training modes, with 16 levels of shock and vibration and tone modes. This lets you pick the safest training mode and shock level for your dog.

An excellent range of 3000 ft range makes this training collar the best pick for long-distance and field training.

Both the e-collar and the transmitter are 100% waterproof. The collar receiver is IPX7 waterproof, and the transmitter is IPX5 rainproof. So you can let your dog play in the pool or train him in the rain without worry.

Patpet Dog Shock Collar

If you want to train two dogs simultaneously, this dual dog training system is a perfect match. You have to purchase an additional collar.

Each button in the remote is easily distinguished by touch. The simple remote design has just 3 buttons from top to bottom. This design lets you focus on your dog while operating the remote.

To ensure the safety of your dog, the remote comes with a security switch. The in-built security lock will prevent any accidental shocks. This safety feature allows you to carry the remote in your pocket without accidentally shocking your dog.

The training system is rapid charging and will fully charge in just 2 hours. The battery life span is pretty great, with the remote having 60 days of standby battery life. The collar has a battery life of 30 days on standby mode.

Pros

3000 ft range
Good battery life
IPX7 waterproof e-collar receiver and IPX5 water-resistant remote
Security switch to prevent accidental shocks

Cons

The LCD screen is not clear in daylight

8. Bousnic Dog Training Collar 

Bousnic Dog Training Collar fits all dog breeds between 15-120 lbs. This adjustable nylon dog collar is for dogs with neck sizes 8-26 inches. 

The training system comes with 3 effective training modes of beep, vibration, and shock.

The shock level is adjustable, so you can start with the lowest setting and find the perfect level to train your dog.

There are 16 levels of shock and 8 levels of vibration to choose from.

A good 1000 ft range lets you use this collar to train your dogs in your house, in the backyard, or in the park.

Bousnic Dog Training Collar

The remote is also equipped with anti-jamming technology. This technology helps to maximize the range and gives a stable connection between the remote and the collar.

Built for dual dog training, the training kit comes with one remote and two receiver collars. So you can train two pups simultaneously.

Touch-distinguished buttons on the remote make it very user-friendly.

The collar receiver is IP67 waterproof, so if you want to let your dog swim or bathe while wearing the collar, this is one of the best option for you.

The battery life is pretty great. The collar batteries will last for about 20 days, while the remote batteries last for 60 days.

Pros

Anti-jamming technology for maximum range
A dual training system that comes with one transmitter and two collars
Good battery life

Cons

It uses AAA batteries that make the collar heavier

9. Petrainer Pet998dru1 Dog Training Collar 

Petrainer Pet998dru1 Dog Training Collar is a good fit for all dog sizes: small, medium, and large.

This fully adjustable collar fits all dogs with neck sizes of 14-25 inches.

Petrainer Dog Training Collar is very popular among newbies to dog training.

Three types of training modes (beep, shock, and vibration) guarantee that you can pick the best train mode for your pup.

And that’s not all; there are 100 adjustable levels for both vibration and shock modes.

With a 1000 ft range, you can use this collar to train your dog in the backyard or park.

Petrainer Pet998dru1 Dog Training Collar

The shock collar is rainproof so that your dog can have a good training session regardless of the weather. However, the collar receiver is not waterproof, so keep in mind to take off the collar when your dog takes a dip in the pool.

Both the transmitter and the collar receiver are rechargeable with lithium batteries. You can charge the remote and the collar simultaneously. The collar has an automatic standby feature to save battery life.

Pros

1000 ft range
100 adjustable levels of vibration and shock
Rechargeable batteries

Cons

The collar is only rainproof
The collar and the remote lose connection at times

10. Dog Care Dog Shock Collar 

Dog Care Dog Shock Collar is a great training collar for dogs between 15-100 lbs and neck sizes 0-27 inches.

This e-collar is a good pick if you want to train many dogs at once.

Beep, vibration, and static mode let you select the best training method for your dog.

There are also 99 levels of shock, so you can pick the lowest safe setting to train your dog.

If you are looking for a security lock, this collar is a good pick.

The extra feature of a security keypad prevents you from accidentally shocking your pup and makes the remote easy to carry in a pocket.

Dog Care Dog Shock Collar

A 1000 ft range gives you long-distance control over your dog. This range is perfect for field training.

The collar receiver is IP67 waterproof and dustproof. This gives your dog more flexibility with outdoor training.

Do you want to train not two or three but nine dogs at once? Then this remote trainer is what you are looking for. You can control more than one dog up to nine dogs with nine channels when you purchase additional collars. This feature makes it perfect for professional dog trainers and dog owners with many stubborn pups.

Both the transmitter and the receiver are rechargeable. The battery life of the transmitter is about 45 days, while the receiver has a battery life of 15 days. The micro USB charging ports allow you to easily charge the whole training system through a power bank or laptop.

Pros

You can train nine dogs with one remote!
Security lock to prevent accidental shocks
1000 ft range
99 levels of static shock

Cons

Collars must be turned on manually by an on/off switch. This is time-consuming.

Buyers Guide: How to Choose the Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs?

a stubborn dog biting a rope

Each e-collar has a different design with a set of unique features. So how can you pick the best training collar for stubborn dogs? When it comes to training a stubborn pup, some features are more important than others.

Here are all the essential features for shock collars.

Collar Length

The first step in buying any dog collar is to measure your dog’s neck. Whatever collar you choose, it must be comfortable for your dog and effective for training.

Loose shock collars are ineffective, and the contact probes can rub your dog’s skin and irritate him. A collar that is too tight is just as uncomfortable.

Shock Intensity

Shock levels and intensities are very important in deciding the best training collar for stubborn dogs.

With stubborn dogs, you might have to use higher shock intensities. Always opt for a collar with many shock levels to pick the lowest, most effective shock for your dog. Some collars will have over 100 levels, while others will have about 20 shock levels.

Range

You must select the best range depending on where you plan to train your dog. The collars we looked at have ranges from 900-3000 ft. If you are looking for an outdoor training collar, pick one with a good range (over 1000 ft is perfect).

For indoor and backyard training, even a lower range would work.

Waterproof Ability

If you plan to let your dog swim or bathe while wearing the training collar, it is best to pick an IPX7 waterproof collar.

Do watch out for the waterproof ability of the remote as well. Most remotes will be IPX5 water-resistant and safe to use in rainy weather.

Waterproof ability is not a big issue if you plan to train your dog indoors.

Security Lock

The security lock is a handy feature for any dog parent worried about accidentally shocking their dogs. Of course, accidental shocks will confuse your dog, but they will also break your dog’s trust in you.

A few collars have the security lock feature, so it cuts down your choices to very few collars if you want the lock feature. This feature is super convenient if you tend to carry the handheld remote in your pocket. 

How Does a Training Collar Work?

Training collars

A training collar is just like a normal dog collar, except that you can control the collar from a distance. Dog training collars come in a set with a remote (transmitter) and a collar (receiver). 

The collar has a set of metal contacts that deliver a small vibration or shock to your dog. It’s totally up to you to choose the training mode and intensity level. Some dog collars (anti-bark collars) automatically detect dog barks and deliver a shock or vibration. 

You can use an electric collar to correct your stubborn dog’s behavior issues like barking, jumping, chasing animals, running away, and digging.

If this information isn’t enough for you and you want to know more about “how does a dog shock collar work”, CLICK HERE!

How to Use a Training Collar on a Stubborn Dog?

It’s quite tricky to train a stubborn dog. Your pup may be willfully stubborn, or maybe he’s just confused and easily distracted. 

Here’s how you can train your stubborn dog:

  • Be patient and take your time with training your dog. You can immediately correct your dog’s behavior with a shock, but the final goal is to make your dog obey you even without a collar. You can achieve this only with time, patience, and consistent training.
  • Use positive reinforcement and praise your stubborn friend when he does something right. This way, you can reinforce good behavior while eliminating bad behavior. 
  • Keep a close watch on your dog when using the vibration and shock modes. Your dog can try to ignore the collar wilfully, but you must never overstimulate him.
  • If your stubborn dog is aggressive when wearing the collar, it’s time to figure out another training method. Training collars are not the best tool for aggressive dogs. You must get help from a professional dog trainer or a veterinarian to determine what’s causing the aggression.

Related: Easy Steps to Train an Aggressive Dog With a Shock Collar

What Are the Benefits of Using Training Collars on Stubborn Dogs?

Training a Stubborn Dog

Now that you’ve decided to buy a training collar, you must be wondering about the benefits you’ll get. Are dog training collars worth the investment? Yes, definitely! Here are all the benefits you’ll be getting from remote training collars:

Long-distance training: With a training collar, you won’t have to follow your dog around the place to correct his behavior. If your dog tries to run away or chase after a cat, all you need to do is use the e-collar to call him back.

No more shouting! : Stubborn dogs can feign to be deaf and ignore you. But with training collars, you can get his attention without shouting.

Want to get your dog’s attention? Beep him. Want to warn your dog? Give a vibration. Want to correct your dog’s behavior in an emergency? Use the shock mode. 

Uses mild shocks: Training collars aren’t the inhumane training tools some claim these to be. Modern collars have very low shock intensities. The correct settings will not hurt your stubborn pup but will get his attention.

Very effective training tool: Training collars are among the most effective tools for stubborn dogs. You might have to use an electric shock only once. After the initial shock, the beep and vibration are good enough to get your dog’s attention.

Less costly: Dog training is expensive! A private dog training session will cost you about $100 or more per session. However, a training collar is much cheaper, and it is a long-term investment. Buy the right collar, and you won’t need another dog training tool for a very long time.

A happier, better-behaved dog: A training collar will strengthen your bond with your dog. Once your dog is well behaved, he can be let off the leash and accompany you anywhere! No more locking your dog away to protect your visitors; your dog can soon be a part of all family events.

FAQs

Yes, e-collars can be an effective training tool for stubborn dogs, and most dogs require only one shock before they learn to obey. However, some more stubborn dogs may need a few extra corrections before they are willing to comply.

The possible reasons for a dog not responding to a training collar can include low battery, a malfunctioning collar, incorrect contact prongs for fur type, increasing shock intensity, and a collar malfunction. To troubleshoot, check the battery, make sure the collar is working, switch contact prongs or trim hair, or increase the shock intensity. If all of these fail, contact the manufacturer.

Conclusion

What’s the best training collar for your stubborn dog? Now’s the time to pick one.

Pet Resolve PTS1200 is undoubtedly the best training collar for stubborn dogs. There are three modes of correction and 10 intensity levels, so it is easy to find the best level for all levels of stubbornness. The 3960 ft range is way more than enough for training.

If money is no object, Halo 2+ is another great pick; it’ll be a complete investment for your dog and will, no doubt, serve you well when it comes to training. 

You are free to make your pick based on the features that matter most to you. Remember to keep your training sessions positive for your stubborn friend, and no matter what collar you select, your dog will be perfectly obedient in no time.

OUR #1 RECOMMENDATION
Pet Resolve PTS1200
Pet Resolve Product Image
Effectiveness
Range
Price

5.0

5.0

5.0

Overall Score

5.0

visa-master-amex-paypal
Pros
Super easy to use the device
Multi-dog system
Collar and the transmitter are excellently durable
Rechargeable collar and transmitter with 50 to 60 hours battery runtime with constant use
2-year warranty
Get the BEST PRICE valid until the end of May
Cons
The remote does not have the ability to turn off the receiver (collar)

Was this article helpful?

User Avatar
Author
Thomas Villalpando
Thomas Villalpando is the main author of IPet Guides. He spends his time reading, training, and working with several Dogs' behaviors. He has been featured in MSN, Yahoo Finance, The Sun, Entrepreneur & More. You can find more about him here.

Leave a Comment